Blue Gate Hospitality Menu (Updated October 2025)

Welcome to Blue Gate Hospitality, a charming American restaurant nestled in the heart of Shipshewana, Indiana. Located at 105 E Middlebury St, this beloved eatery combines homestyle cooking with a warm and inviting atmosphere that transports you back in time.

Blue Gate boasts a diverse menu featuring hearty favorites that bring families together. For a delightful lunch or dinner, try the Amish Beef & Noodles on Mondays for just US$14.99, or savor the much-loved Homestyle Meatloaf on Tuesdays, priced at US$16.49. Don't miss Fish Fry Friday for a crispy treat at US$17.49. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring you find comfort in every bite.

Customer reviews laud the generous portions and remarkable flavors, with many guests highlighting the captivating decor filled with antiques that add to the restaurant's charm. Patrons like David Rust and Jaclynn Hamilton emphasize the quality of service and the delightful atmosphere that encourages leisurely meals.

For dessert enthusiasts, the in-house bakery is highly recommended, showcasing decadent fudge and pies that will satisfy any sweet tooth. At Blue Gate Hospitality, you don't just dine — you create cherished memories over a table filled with delicious, homestyle meals.